Should PCB Appoint Shoaib Malik Captain Once Again?

Here are some statements of players and officials regarding Shoaib Malik before the Inquiry Committee after complete failure of Pakistan team in Australia…  

Then Coach Intikhab Alam 

"He (Malik) is a negative person and he creates problems. I wanted him to be sent back home," 

Shahid Afridi blamed him for back biting and said,   

"I told him clearly on his face that if he continues this practice of his double standards he will not survive in the team for too long and I will not have him in the team if I am made captain," 

Muhammad Yousuf 

"He played politics all the time. Former chairman, Dr Nasim Ashraf made a big blunder and hurt Pakistan cricket when he appointed Malik captain in 2007 when his place in the side was also not confirmed. This led to other players also believing they could become captain, it set a wrong precedent in Pakistan cricket," 

Former assistant coach Aaqib Javed also has no good words for Malik but insists that the Shoiab Malik is not the only one creating problems in the team. 

A committee member remarks about Malik   

"Dimak ki tarah tha wo (He was like termite)."

There are some media reports that Pakistan cricket coach Dav Whatmore and ex PCB chairman Ijaz Butt are in favour of Shoaib Malik as Captain. But before appointing him captain again, PCB Chairman Zaka Ashraf and Coach Dav Whatmore should read these negative statements once again and then decide for Shoaib Malik future role. They must analyze these statements and should find the reasons for these statements.